Zillow Group’s antitrust fight with Midwest Real Estate Data, the Lisle-based MLS covering the Chicago region, is headed to arbitration after a federal judge declined to grant the real estate platform preliminary relief in its battle over the Chicago-area listing feed. The ruling sends Zillow’s claims against MRED to arbitration and puts related litigation against brokerage Compass on hold, according to Bloomberg’s account of the decision.

The dispute has been Chicago’s messiest real estate story all year. It began in May, when MRED — the nation’s third-largest multiple listing service — cut off its direct listing feed to Zillow over the portal’s listing access standards policy, which MRED argued violated its license agreement. Overnight, roughly two-thirds of Zillow’s Chicago home listings vanished from Zillow and Trulia, leaving potential buyers browsing a hollowed-out inventory page and forcing Chicagoland agents to redirect clients to broker sites.

Zillow sued, won a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction attempt, and a judge initially ordered MRED to restore the feed while the case proceeded. In September, however, US District Judge John Tharp Jr. dissolved that relief and ruled against Zillow’s bid to force MRED to provide access, handing the MLS and the private-listing movement a notable win. This month’s follow-up ruling — denying the injunction, compelling arbitration, and staying the Compass litigation to avoid inconsistent rulings — effectively ends the courtroom phase of the feud and moves it to a private forum.

The stakes go far beyond one portal’s Chicago feed. MRED’s Private Listing Network, which hosts pre-marketed listings shown only to member agents, is at the center of the fight: Zillow argues private networks fragment the market and keep listings away from consumers, while MRED and Compass defend the practice as agents’ contractual right. Zillow’s own researchers previously found that homes in MRED’s private network are more likely to be in majority-white neighborhoods — a claim the company used to argue private listings “reinforce segregation,” which MRED disputes.

For Chicago homebuyers and sellers, the arbitration path means the current uneasy truce probably holds through the winter. Listings remain available through brokerage websites and the MLS’s member systems regardless of the Zillow outcome, but consumer access to the largest national portal stays reduced until either an arbitration award or a negotiated data-sharing deal resolves the standoff.

The case has become a national bellwether. Trade press coverage of the September loss framed Judge Tharp’s denial as a federal stamp of approval for private listing networks, and a second major MLS has already threatened to follow MRED’s lead in cutting Zillow’s feed. If arbitration upholds the MLS’s position, portals could find their ability to aggregate listings across markets fundamentally constrained — an outcome with multi-billion-dollar implications for Zillow’s traffic-driven model and for the listing-access standards it has pushed nationwide.

Neither side has announced settlement talks, and the arbitration schedule has not been publicly disclosed. Zillow declined to comment beyond its filings; MRED has said its agreements with Zillow contain mandatory arbitration clauses that it asked the court to enforce — and this month, the court agreed.